annie haslam and Paul Mauriat version of Bach's favorite

[webbburt777]

what do you think of this vocal version?

[Thomas R. Sareks]

Post by webbburt777
http://youtu.be/3u23zVeQwLQ
what do you think of this vocal version?

I think you should be cruzified with rusty nails. Ten times, just to be
sure.




-t.

[Arthur Ness]

Well, it is an aria. I've always wondered when someone would find the
lyrics.<g>
==============================================

Post by Thomas R. Sareks

Post by webbburt777
http://youtu.be/3u23zVeQwLQ
what do you think of this vocal version?

I think you should be cruzified with rusty nails. Ten times, just to be
sure.
-t.

[Mark & Steven Bornfeld]

Post by Arthur Ness
Well, it is an aria. I've always wondered when someone would find the
lyrics.<g>

As William Demarest once said in (I think the movie was "Don't Be
Afraid of the Dark"):

"Some tings ah bettuh left undeestoibed!"

Steve

Post by Arthur Ness
==============================================

Post by Thomas R. Sareks

Post by webbburt777
http://youtu.be/3u23zVeQwLQ
what do you think of this vocal version?

I think you should be cruzified with rusty nails. Ten times, just to be
sure.
-t.

[Arthur Ness]

Yes, I'd agree. It's rather sacchrine.

And probably the original Air should have been left alone, too. It is
called Air on the G string because some 19th-century violinist used it as an
encore piece. He transposed it, so that he could play it all on the G
string. Bach's doesn't use just the G string. And that is an improper
designation, when it's not played all on the G string. But it's cute name
for a bikini, so it sticks.

Now should Bach have left "undeestoibed" Weiss's lute sonata when he added a
violin part to it? IF he did. (See the present thread on
rec.music.classical.guitar.)

Post by Arthur Ness
Well, it is an aria. I've always wondered when someone would find the
lyrics.<g>

As William Demarest once said in (I think the movie was "Don't Be Afraid
"Some tings ah bettuh left undeestoibed!"
Steve

Post by Arthur Ness
==============================================

Post by Thomas R. Sareks

Post by webbburt777
http://youtu.be/3u23zVeQwLQ
what do you think of this vocal version?

I think you should be cruzified with rusty nails. Ten times, just to be
sure.
-t.

--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
718-258-5001

[Mark & Steven Bornfeld]

Post by Arthur Ness
Yes, I'd agree. It's rather sacchrine.
And probably the original Air should have been left alone, too. It is
called Air on the G string because some 19th-century violinist used it as an
encore piece. He transposed it, so that he could play it all on the G
string. Bach's doesn't use just the G string. And that is an improper
designation, when it's not played all on the G string. But it's cute name
for a bikini, so it sticks.
Now should Bach have left "undeestoibed" Weiss's lute sonata when he added a
violin part to it? IF he did. (See the present thread on
rec.music.classical.guitar.)

Thanks for pointing this out--I'd mostly missed this.

Steve